SF QuorumQuorum
Back to legislation
Charter Amendment#240552Passed
In plain English

This legislation amends the city charter to adjust the age factor percentage for retirement benefits for new members of the Fire Department, allowing them to reach a higher percentage at younger ages and lowering the maximum retirement age for this benefit from 58 to 55. The changes will be voted on in the election scheduled for November 5, 2024.

Charter Amendment (Third Draft) to amend the Charter of the City and County of San Francisco to change the age factor percentage for benefit calculations such that persons who have or will become members of the Fire Department on and after January 7, 2012 reach a higher age factor percentage at earlier ages and lower from 58 to 55 the retirement age at which persons who have or will become members of the Fire Department on and after January 7, 2012 reach the highest age factor percentage; at an election to be held on November 5, 2024.

Introduced: May 21, 2024
Final action: Jul 30, 2024
Official record β†—

How it got here

The Charter Amendment to reform the Fire Department's retirement pension system originated from the need to address the financial impacts of previous pension reforms and the unique health risks faced by firefighters.

1
Approval of Proposition CNovember 2011
San Francisco Voters

Voters approved Proposition C, which reformed the City’s retirement and health benefits systems, increasing pension contribution rates and raising retirement ages for new firefighters.

Legislative Digest
2
Introduction of Charter AmendmentMay 2024
Board of Supervisors

The Board introduced a Charter Amendment to change the age factor percentage for benefit calculations and lower the retirement age for firefighters hired after January 7, 2012.

Legislative Digest
3
CEQA DeterminationMay 28, 2024
Rules Committee

The Rules Committee referred the Charter Amendment to the Planning Department for CEQA review, determining it would not result in a physical change in the environment.

CEQA Determination
4
Amendment of Charter AmendmentJuly 8, 2024
Rules Committee

The Rules Committee amended the Charter Amendment to refine the language and clarify the changes to the retirement benefits.

Action History
5
Committee ReportJuly 22, 2024
Rules Committee

The Rules Committee recommended the Charter Amendment as a committee report to the Board of Supervisors.

Committee Report
6
Election DateNovember 5, 2024
San Francisco Voters

The Charter Amendment will be presented to voters for approval in the upcoming election.

Legislative Digest

Reconstructed from attached documents & the official record

Document trail
PDF β†—
Leg Dig Ver1
Official legislation text
PDF β†—
PDF β†—
PDF β†—
PDF β†—
Referral CEQA 052824
Environmental review (CEQA)
PDF β†—
CEQA Determination 062524
Environmental review (CEQA)
PDF β†—
PDF β†—
PDF β†—
PDF β†—
PDF β†—
Leg Dig Ver2
Official legislation text
PDF β†—
CEQA Determination 071024
Environmental review (CEQA)
PDF β†—
PDF β†—
PDF β†—
PDF β†—
PDF β†—
PDF β†—
PDF β†—
Leg Dig Ver3
Official legislation text
PDF β†—
CEQA Referral 071624
Environmental review (CEQA)
PDF β†—
PDF β†—
PDF β†—
PDF β†—
CEQA Determination 071724
Environmental review (CEQA)
PDF β†—
PDF β†—
PDF β†—
PDF β†—
PDF β†—
PDF β†—
PDF β†—
Transmittal to Elections 080124
Departmental transmittal
PDF β†—

How they voted

ORDERED SUBMITTED
Board of Supervisors Β· Jul 30, 2024Pass
4-0 /1
RECOMMENDED AS COMMITTEE REPORT
Rules Committee Β· Jul 22, 2024Pass
1-0
AMENDED, AN AMENDMENT OF THE WHOLE BEARING NEW TITLE
Rules Committee Β· Jul 15, 2024Pass
1-0
CONTINUED AS AMENDED
Rules Committee Β· Jul 15, 2024Pass
1-0
AMENDED, AN AMENDMENT OF THE WHOLE BEARING NEW TITLE
Rules Committee Β· Jul 8, 2024Pass
1-0
CONTINUED AS AMENDED
Rules Committee Β· Jul 8, 2024Pass
1-0

Legislative journey

PresidentMay 21, 2024
β†’ASSIGNED UNDER 30 DAY RULE
Clerk of the BoardMay 28, 2024
β†’REFERRED TO DEPARTMENT
Rules CommitteeJul 8, 2024
β†·CONTINUED AS AMENDEDPass
✎AMENDED, AN AMENDMENT OF THE WHOLE BEARING NEW TITLEPass
Clerk of the BoardJul 9, 2024
β†’REFERRED TO DEPARTMENT
Rules CommitteeJul 15, 2024
β†·CONTINUED AS AMENDEDPass
✎AMENDED, AN AMENDMENT OF THE WHOLE BEARING NEW TITLEPass
Clerk of the BoardJul 16, 2024
β†’REFERRED TO DEPARTMENT
Rules CommitteeJul 22, 2024
βœ“RECOMMENDED AS COMMITTEE REPORTPass
Board of SupervisorsJul 23, 2024 – Jul 30, 2024
β†·CONTINUEDPass
Β·ORDERED SUBMITTEDPass
Clerk of the BoardAug 1, 2024
Β·TRANSMITTED